Only some do. A south window in Kyiv (50° N) gives roughly 2.0 mol/m²/day in December (an estimate), around the minimum of foliage plants whose winter target is 2–6: it may hold them. In Kyiv, Moscow or Helsinki, orchids, herbs and anything you want to keep growing need a lamp. Plants that rest in winter, such as aloe, need none.
What a December window gives
Winter light is weak, and Iowa State Extension notes that indoor intensity is often very low then. The window light model in RootQ's calculators estimates it from the city's latitude, facing, distance from the glass, glazing and the city's average cloudiness month by month, so two cities on one latitude differ. These are estimates: read each as roughly half to one and a half times the number.
Assumptions: mid-December, double glazing, no obstruction, the pot 0.1 m from the glass.
| City | South | East or west | North | South, 0.5 m back |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kyiv (50° N) | South2.0 | East or west1.2 | North0.9 | South, 0.5 m back1.6 |
| Moscow (56° N) | South1.1 | East or west0.6 | North0.5 | South, 0.5 m back0.9 |
| Helsinki (60° N) | South0.5 | East or west0.3 | North0.2 | South, 0.5 m back0.4 |
Estimated DLI, mol/m²/day. Moving a pot 0.5 m back from the glass costs about a fifth of the December dose.
What the plants want
Winter targets from the knowledge base, set against the south sill in Moscow (about 1.1 mol/m²/day, estimate):
| Group | Winter DLI, mol/m²/day | Hours | South sill, Moscow | Lamp, W for 0.25 m² |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Monstera and other tropical foliage | Winter DLI, mol/m²/day2–6 | Hours10–12 | South sill, Moscowborderline | Lamp, W for 0.25 m²8 |
| Calathea and other humidity-loving foliage | Winter DLI, mol/m²/day2–5 | Hours10–12 | South sill, Moscowborderline | Lamp, W for 0.25 m²8 |
| Succulents at rest (aloe, ZZ) | Winter DLI, mol/m²/day1–10 | Hours10–12 | South sill, Moscowenough | Lamp, W for 0.25 m²4 |
| Phalaenopsis | Winter DLI, mol/m²/day4–12 | Hours12–14 | South sill, Moscowinsufficient | Lamp, W for 0.25 m²14 |
| Woody herbs at rest (rosemary) | Winter DLI, mol/m²/day4–10 | Hours10–12 | South sill, Moscowinsufficient | Lamp, W for 0.25 m²16 |
| Leafy herbs (basil) | Winter DLI, mol/m²/day12–17 | Hours14–16 | South sill, Moscowinsufficient | Lamp, W for 0.25 m²34 |
The verdict follows the app's rule: at or above the minimum is enough; below it but within 70% of it once the ±50% error is allowed for is borderline; anything lower is insufficient. The lamp column is the whole minimum from the lamp alone; the window adds about 1. The text below reads the whole range of the estimate instead: a sill is enough only when even half its figure reaches the minimum, and short only when even the top of the range stays below it.
For which plants a lamp changes anything
- Orchids and herbs. The gap to the target is large. A lamp turns "alive" into "growing".
- Foliage plants. A south sill in Kyiv, 2.0, sits around their minimum of 2: they may hold, slowly, and stretched growth that leans to the glass says the sill is not enough. In Moscow and Helsinki even one and a half times the south sill's estimate, 1.1 and 0.5, stays under 2. East, west and north sills fall short in all three cities, and a small lamp brings them to the target.
- Resting succulents. Their winter target is 1 mol/m²/day. A south sill in Kyiv, 2.0, is just enough; in Moscow, 1.1, it sits around the minimum. A lamp changes little; cool, dry rest is the point.
How much lamp
The grow light calculator takes a target PPFD, an area, whether the lamp is in a room (65% of the light lands on the plants) or a tent (85%) and the lamp's efficacy. A modern LED gives 2.7 µmol/J, a budget LED 1.8. The budget one needs 1.5 times the watts.
For 55 µmol/m²/s over 0.25 m², a modern LED in a room needs about 8 W. Leafy herbs at 240 µmol/m²/s over 0.1 m² need about 14 W, or about 34 W over 0.25 m². Check the dose with the DLI calculator: PPFD × hours × 0.0036. If you measure a window with a lux meter, the lux to PPFD calculator converts it. Iowa State advises 12–14 hours for houseplants and allows 10–16 for home growers, so a timer set to 12 hours is a safe default for foliage plants.
Hours trade against intensity. A Phalaenopsis at 100 µmol/m²/s reaches 4.3 mol/m²/day in 12 hours and 5.0 in 14. As DLI basics advises, raise the intensity before the hours when a plant needs more, because very long days are not free.
Next: houseplant care in winter for watering and heating, and herbs on a windowsill in winter.
Where to hang it and when to stop
The app treats lamp height as a warning, not part of the estimate, because home growers rarely have the lamp's light curve. Typical hanging heights are 20–60 cm for a modern LED and 15–45 cm for a budget one; a datasheet wins over these. Measure PPFD at leaf height, as in DLI basics, and average several points.
A worked example. A monstera on an east sill in Moscow gets about 0.6 mol/m²/day in December (estimate). Its winter minimum is 2. A modern LED giving 55 µmol/m²/s at the leaf for 12 hours adds 2.4, so the total is about 3.0, inside the 2–6 band.
When the window catches up
The same south sill in Moscow, 0.1 m from the glass, estimated by the same model for the middle of each month:
| Month | Nov | Dec | Jan | Feb | Mar |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| DLI, mol/m²/day | Nov1.6 | Dec1.1 | Jan2.1 | Feb5.6 | Mar11.0 |
In mid-January, at 2.1, the sill alone only sits around the foliage minimum of 2. By mid-February it reaches 5.6, and even half of that is above 2, so the lamp can go off for tropical and humidity-loving foliage. Leafy herbs still need it: their minimum is 12, and even the top of the estimate's range falls short of it. A Phalaenopsis, with a minimum of 4, sits around it in February and has enough by March.
Limits
The window figures are one model, not a measurement. A tree, a curtain or a dirty pane cuts them. Do not light the nights of photoperiod-sensitive plants: a Christmas cactus (Schlumbergera) needs at least 13 hours of full darkness every night while buds form.